Germanwings tragedy – viewpoints

The loss of 4U 952524 March left us all with a deep feeling of sadness. Like anyone else, pilots across Europe were thinking about the victims, their families & friends, and looking for answers: “How could this happen?” Seeing how the lives of 150 people on board European aircraft, with European crew perished in a moment is one of our unspoken nightmares. Could we have done something to prevent it? For sure, there will be lessons to learn from this tragedy. The pilots’ professional duty is to strive for improving safety and we will put all our efforts into this, as stated after the crash.

However, in the aftermath of the crash many things have been said and written. Newspaper and magazine articles, TV news, documentaries, blog posts or opinion pieces ranging from pure sensationalism to high quality journalism, offered tribune to known and unknown aviation ‘experts’. This is why we do not offer you another article on this tragedy. Yet, we also believe that you have the right to be informed. In the sea of stories and opinions, there were some voices, which caught our attention and made us think, question and look for answers ourselves.

We have selected for you a number of articles, opinion pieces and information bulletins. While these articles do not necessarily reflect an ECA position, they do contain thought-provoking elements and ideas. 

Alps plane crash: What happened?– BBC factsheet

The co-pilot of a Germanwings flight that crashed into the French Alps sent the plane into its doomed descent "intentionally", according to French investigators. […] Speculation over the reasons for his actions has centred around the co-pilot's mental wellbeing.

EU Commission Factsheet on EU security measures in civil airliners

There is a European Regulation which mandates that pilots must have a current Medical Certificate. This certificate is issued by an approved specialist in aviation medicine and revalidated at regular intervals throughout a pilots' career. Within the European Regulations for Medical Certificates there are requirements that relate to psychiatry and psychology.

EASA recommends minimum two crew in the cockpit

EASA ‘s  temporary recommendation for airlines to ensure that at least two crew, including at least one qualified pilot, are in the flight crew compartment at all times of the flight. Airlines should re-assess the safety and security risks associated with a flight crew leaving the cockpit due to operational or physiological needs. Other mitigation measures are possible too.

Two-Person Flight Deck Action Following Germanwings Crash…The Right Action?

On the surface, it might seem like a sensible move. Perhaps it is. But with calls for more action increasing, should the industry go further?

Germanwings flight 4U9525: what’s it like to listen to a black box recording?

After every air disaster, finding the black box recorder becomes the first priority – but for the crash investigators who have to listen to the tapes of people’s final moments, the experience can be incredibly harrowing.

Pilots’ union: Germanwings CVR data leak ‘serious breach’ of rules

“The leaking of the CVR data is a serious breach of fundamental and globally accepted international accident investigation rules. The motivation for and consequences of this will need to be addressed,” ECA said.

Aviation must address risk within the cockpit

Pilots work in one of the most checked and tested of professions. More checks might add to stress, which is harmful in itself. And things change quickly. A stable pilot one day can, after a family or career misfortune, be under severe stress the next. But improved assessment may be possible, so this needs careful study.

Captain Patrick Sondheimer. That’s the pilot’s name you want to remember.

There aren’t any photos of him. There aren’t any headlines. But Patrick Sondheimer was the captain who was piloting the plane with Lubitz.

The Germanwings tragedy: inside the mind of a pilot

As a qualified pilot and psychiatrist, I am certain that no prior psychological test to Andreas Lubitz would have predicted his actions.

Alps tragedy exposes relentless pressures faced by commercial pilots

If anything good comes out of the Germanwings crash, it may be that the conditions faced by pilots working for budget airlines will be scrutinised.

You Call this an Investigation? Germanwings So Far Anything But Conclusive

[…] air accidents in France are seen through the prism of criminality rather than as in other countries where seasoned air safety investigators understand there is a multitude of factors that contribute to a disaster and will wait to have evidence before drawing conclusions.

GermanWings 4U9525: Falsenotes In Established Narrative.

In the race between media houses to “Breaking News”, “instant leaks” and “possible theories” start doing rounds, and with their endless repetitions soon acquire aura of infallible truth; no doubt, aided by dubious experts acting as talking heads holding forth dearly to "their version" on talk-shows. This is the tragedy of 24x7 news that highly speculative and presumptive narratives parroted by high priests of MSM overtake completely serious and methodical investigations to the point of rendering them infructuous.

Mental Health Screening Wouldn't Have Saved Germanwings 9525

The dilemma with these screening standards is the same dilemma with any medical screening program: how to avoid catching “false positive” and missing “false negative” results.